VIENNESE VERDICTS | The EBJ Jury Reviews (Part 1)

IT’S TIME!!! With Eurovision so close I could almost touch it (if I had ridiculously long arms) it’s beyond appropriate for me to kick off my 2015 reviews right here, right now. But wait – there’s more!

For the first time this year, I decided I wasn’t going to review song after song (after song) all on my lonesome. Not when, thanks to modern technology, I knew I had army of Eurovision fanatics from all over the globe at my disposal. Granted, the recruitment ended with the EBJ Jury mostly being made up of Australians, but…what can I say? Together, we’re large and in charge. Kind of.

The EBJ Jury, in case you were wondering, is the highly imaginative name I came up with to describe the slaves hard-working fans I duped into helping me out. Each week, a different pair of ESC obsessives (though some faces will appear on a few occasions) will join me to judge five of the songs that will take to the Wiener Stadthalle stage next month. We’ll each award these songs ESC-style points (what else?) and I’ll calculate an average figure that will become that country’s ranking score. It’s all pretty straightforward, though I know I’ve made it seem the opposite.

So, are you up for meeting today’s jurors? I hope so, because here they are!

 

TODAY’S EBJ JURY

vv1Rory Gannon: “HELL-OHHHHH guys! My name is Rory and I am the beautiful (ish) age of 16. I currently co-run a little blog called ESC Views (where your Eurovision views are brought to you..or are they?!) and…well, I suppose I’m pretty much the definition of a non-conforming Eurovision fan; in other words, if there’s a fanwank *ahem* Sweden *ahem*, I’m sure to hate it! I’ve been to two magnificent Eurovisions – Düsseldorf in 2011 and Malmö in 2013 – I know, jealous much? *wink* Oh, and just so you know, I didn’t cheer for my homeland of Ireland – that really just ain’t my thing! My favourite songs from Eurovision would have to include the AMAYYYYZIN My Słowianie (I know, weird right?!), Ein Lied Kann Eine Brücke Sein aaaaaand……hmm., Birds too. It is quite an odd range, but, myeh, each to their own!”

ESC Views | ESC Views on Facebook

Matt Kelly: “I’m Matt from Adelaide (or Radelaide, as the locals like to refer to it), Australia. I “star” in a Eurovision show on YouTube called escTMI (I know, I need to get a life). In 2013 I was lucky enough to do the pilgrimage to Malmö to attend my first Eurovision. What a dream it was. This year I’ll be doing that loong flight to Europe again to attend the contest in Vienna.”

escTMI on YouTube | escTMI on Facebook

Jasmin Bear: “My name is Jasmin, but I’m known in Eurovision circles as ‘Jaz’. I’m guessing you’re somewhat familiar with me as you’re currently reading my blog. Eurovision is my life passion, even if my family and (some of) my friends can’t comprehend that, and I think about it on average six times a minute. I’ve never attended a contest, but you can bet your plagiarized stick-figure man that if Sweden wins in Vienna – and, to be honest, even if they don’t – I’m going in 2016, gosh darn it! My all-time favourite ESC entry is Lane Moje by Željko Joksimovic, as I’m a sucker for a big Balkan ballad, and I truly believe that Sanna Nielsen is angel sent from Eurovision and/or Melodifestivalen heaven…a place I’m very keen to visit in the distant future.”

 
Now we’re all acquainted, let’s get cracking on EBJ’s 2015 reviews – reviews that are being conducted collaboratively for the first time in my five-and-a-half-year history. Y’all must be so relieved to be getting a break from my solo Eurovisual ramblings.

*awkward silence*

Ahem. We’ll begin with Russia, and continue with Austria, France, Ireland and Serbia.

 

RUSSIA
A Million Voices by Polina Gagarina

Russia

Rory: Ooohh….okay, I’m going to try not to offend anyone if I can, but that might a bit of a mammoth task! So yeah, I’m pretty much neutral on Russia’s song this year. I mean, the song is okay, a tad mediocre if I’m to say something negative about it, but Polina is a great singer. And also, I really don’t agree with the whole booing Russian artists thing – don’t blame Polina, Masha, Nastya or Dima – they didn’t do anything. Join in with Stephane & 3G and blame Putin! Getting back to the actual song here, I’m sure it’ll do well and I hope Polina does do well, but it’s just not the sort of song I would find myself listening to post-Eurovision. 4 points.

Matt: I love an anthem – a song that you can sing along to in the car at the top of your lungs. A Million Voices is an anthem with a beautiful message of peace and acceptance. The video is gorgeous, filled with beautiful, happy children dancing around with Polina. It almost has me believing that everything in the world is hunky-dory. This song would be one my favourites if it was from any country other than Russia. Why does Russia keep sending these anthems of world peace? It’s such a joke and it’s nothing more than propaganda. I know Eurovision is a song contest, and politics shouldn’t come into it, but Polina is representing her country, and the song’s message is totally contradictory to Russian politics. Russia, next year, please think about sending a simple song about love, and maybe people won’t be so upset. Cue the booing. 7 points.

Jaz: Another year, another “inspirational” ballad from Russia about peace, love and understanding, and all that nausea-inducing schmaltz. There’s very little authenticity to this entry, from the cliché lyrics to the fact that few – if any – Russians were involved in writing them (I know a ton of countries search internationally for songs, but that kind of shopping around always rubs me up the wrong way). And yet, the package is partially saved by a) a decent melody; b) a big, instant chorus; and c) Polina’s mesmerising looks and powerful (at least within the walls of a recording studio) voice. So I’m torn. It’s 2015, and this isn’t a song you’d hear outside of Eurovision, unless Celine Dion was performing it during the opening ceremony of the Olympic Games. That aspect, I dislike. But A Million Voices is the less cheesy cousin of 2013’s What If, which I did end up falling for and which gave Russia a very good result. I’m giving it a conflicted 6 points.

EBJ Jury Score: 5.66

 

AUSTRIA
I Am Yours by The Makemakes

Austria

Rory: Hmm..I really am quite indifferent to Austria this year. Okay, the song as a standalone would fare very well in terms of being on the radio and trying to promote an album of some sort, but this is a competition we’re talking about here – you either have to make a mark on people’s minds or get out, and Austria aren’t managing to make that happen this year. I hope they do well, purely for the fact that they’re gonna put on a great show, but that’s pretty much it for me. 5 points.

Matt: Austria has sent another attractive bearded singer with flowing locks. The MakeMakes’ song I Am Yours is everything a host country wants: it’s a nice, easy-listening, inoffensive song that won’t come last and definitely won’t win. The song starts off promisingly, evoking thoughts of Coldplay, but you soon realise it’s going nowhere. It’s repetitive and just plain dull. Not even setting the piano on fire can manage to inject interest into the performance. 6 points.

Jaz: Host entries usually fall into one of two categories – either they’re lacklustre as heck because the host country has bigger fish to fry and/or doesn’t want to win again; or they’re epic, presumably by accident when the host country stopped trying too hard to pick a winner because they didn’t have to. I Am Yours, however, is a mixture of the two for me. While I accept that it’s low-key and unlikely to trouble the top of the scoreboard (which for some people, would make it lacklustre) I really enjoy listening to it, and I think it’s an entry Austria should be proud to present to Europe (and Australia) on home soil. The resemblances the chorus bears to Coldplay’s The Scientist might give it a flicker of familiarity that works in its favour come May. The Makemakes make (#hadto) for a very nice, if not ground-breaking, choice to succeed Conchita. 7 points.

EBJ Jury Score: 6.00

 

FRANCE
N’oubliez Pas by Lisa Angell

Les Grands du Rire; tournage; Lisa Angell  |

Rory: When I heard this song for the first time, I didn’t quite get it. For me, N’oubliez Pas was just another ballad flower in the meadow. But after listening to it for a few months, I do feel like it has grown on me. It’s a little bit like Riverdance: it starts off really timid and quiet and it grows and grows until you get the dramatic climax at the end of the song. Lisa can deliver the song well live, but I just hope she can manage to repeat it onstage in Vienna – let’s face it, the French need it! 7 points.

Matt: The French entries always seem to cop a lot of flack and I’m not sure why. The good thing is it doesn’t seem to deter them. If something doesn’t work one year, they send something totally different the next. Lisa Angell is a million miles away from 2014’s Twin Twin. Her song is a haunting ballad that’s totally old-school Eurovision. It builds in all the right places and ends with a bang right on the three-minute mark. In a year full of ladies singing ballads, N’oubliez Pas is the most sophisticated – the Chanel of ballads. 7 points.

Jaz: I don’t know how much I have to say about France this year, aside from BRING BACK THE MOUSTACHE! How many adjectives can you employ to describe a rather anonymous, bordering-on-pretty ballad? A ballad that’s competing in a field overgrowing with similar, arguably better songs? This is perfectly acceptable. It plods along nicely, and Lisa performs it like the seasoned professional she is, giving those of us non-fluent in French just enough emotion to realise there’s a story behind the song…even if we’re not 100% on what it is until we Google it. But does it excite me like Twin Twin’s quirky mod-pop did? Nope. Will N’oubliez Pas fare better than last place with two points? Oui, but that means little to me. I’d rather support an entry that floats my boat and watch it fail than see one that makes me feel nothing succeed. 5 points.

EBJ Jury Score: 6.33

 

IRELAND
Playing With Numbers by Molly Sterling

Ireland

Rory: I’m trying not to sound like a patriotic twat, but I swear to god, this normally doesn’t happen! I – for once – love my country’s song! Well, I’d have much preferred Erika instead, but Playing With Numbers was always going to be a close second place. I will admit, the song is a bit of a grower, but with all the recaps that ORF will be showing, surely that little segment will stick in people’s minds! No? Plus, I MET the one and only Molly backstage after she won (that’s right, we’re going up in the world!!) and OMG, guys, she is such a modest person for a 17-year-old. Don’t deny her the chance of showcasing her work to the world! 10 points.

Matt: Molly was my favourite from this year’s Irish selection. She was the most original and talented participant, but I’m not sure Ireland’s best will be good enough, which is a shame as Ireland has had really bad luck in the last couple of years of the contest. The song is nice – think Missy Higgins – but it isn’t interesting enough to stand out from the other, bigger ballads. I think people will listen to this for a minute, then take the opportunity to head to the loo. 5 points.

Jaz: No need to call the doctor, folks – I can tell you right here, right now that what Ireland is suffering from is a classic case of Grower Syndrome. My prescription: repeated listens that, if you’re anything like me, will have you head over heels for Playing With Numbers in no time. The first time I heard this, my brain went ‘meh’, although I was relieved Ireland had selected one of the most decent songs possible. But the more ear-time I gave to Molly’s three minutes, the more I found myself appreciating the sentiment of the song – and thinking ‘Dayum gurl, that chorus is catchy!’. Compare Playing With Numbers to Russia’s song, and it’s clear that Ireland has the authenticity and believable sentiment that Russia lacks. No doubt Molly will struggle to hit Polina’s heights, but if nothing else, I can happily say this: all is forgiven, Ireland, for that aesthetically-displeasing car crash of Copenhagen. 8 points.

EBJ Jury Score: 7.66

 

SERBIA
Beauty Never Lies by Bojana Stamenov

Serbia

Rory: I really do like Serbia this year. It was always a sure thing that Bojana was going to represent them – she obviously had the most sass up on that stage! It did seem a bit better in its original Serbian version, but it still has that captivating and empowering message behind it and for that, I’d like to applaud Miss Stabmyknife for her ability to draw us into her performance. I just hope first-time listeners can understand the same feeling on the night! 7 points.

Matt: Oh, a diva singing a huge anthem! Yes please, and thank you Serbia – you rarely disappoint. Bojana Stamenov just blows me away. Her voice is huge. Sure, the English version of the song is a little clichéd and I do prefer the original Serbian version, but it’s brilliantly crafted. It starts out slowly and quietly, then slowly builds, and at the 1:45 mark, the disco beat kicks in and Bojana grabs you by the hand and drags you onto the dance floor. It takes me to Eurovision heaven. Amazing. 10 points.

Jaz: Oh, Serbia. What has become of you? You were once a country who could be relied upon to provide beautiful, mystical and always classy Balkan ballads. Now, after a costume-related disaster and a year of Eurovision vacation (minus JESC) you’ve come back not so much with a bang as with a fart noise. Beauty Never Lies definitely stinks, IMO – not because of Bojana, whose voice, like the Wizard of Oz, is great and powerful. It’s not even due to the song itself, since music-and-melody-wise, it’s fine. But once Ceo Svet Je Moj became Beauty Never Lies, it dropped from the halfway range of my Top 40 ranking to the very bottom. The English rewrite of this song is dreadful, packed with lame lyrics that take power away from the song rather than boosting it. I don’t think a Eurovision song has ever come this close to actually making me vomit before. Shame on you, Serbia. 1 point for the melody + 2 points for Bojana = 3 points.

EBJ Jury Score: 6.66

 

 

That’s it for the first episode of Viennese Verdicts, folks. After five catty and complimentary reviews, the EBJ Jury standings are as follows:

1. Ireland (7.66)
2. Serbia (6.66)
3. France (6.33)
4. Austria (6.00)
5. Russia (5.66)

I’ll be revealing the EBJ Jury Top 40 in the final episode, mid-May. For now, 35 songs remain for us to comment on, and any one of them has the potential to sweep Miss Sterling off the top of the list, or bump Polina from the bottom. You’ve already witnessed how different fan opinions can be (Serbia certainly divided us!) so anything could happen.

For Part 2 of the Viennese Verdicts, I’m bringing you my thoughts on the entries from the Netherlands, Norway, Slovenia, Iceland and Switzerland – with the added perspectives of an American Eurovision aficionado, and my mum. Yes, you read that right – Mrs. Jaz was roped into reviewing some of the 2015 competitors. And let me tell you, getting her to be honest was not a problem.

While you’re waiting (on the edge of your seats, I’m sure) for that, answer me this in the comments: how do your rankings of Ireland, Serbia, France, Austria and Russia stack up against the EBJ Jury’s? Who read your mind with their reviews, and who had you concerned for the state of their mental health? Sharing is caring, so let us know below!

 

Until next time…

nsig

 

About Jaz

I'm Jaz, I'm 26, and I'm 110% Eurovision-OBSESSED. The contest is one big party, and I like to keep it going 365 days a year - that's why I write about anything and everything ESC on my blog. Come join the fun, and I promise you'll never have a nul-point experience! www.eurovisionbyjaz.com/

Posted on April 20, 2015, in Eurovision 2015, Reviews and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 9 Comments.

  1. I was going to offer my services to help out on one of your juries but I think my views would be totally at odds with everyone else! I would almost go so far as to say that I’d have your five the other way up…

    Russia at the bottom of those five? REALLY? I know you haven’t been watching recent performances but Polina’s live performances are absolutely amazing and she will be getting big points in Vienna, believe me! An almost certain top 5 this year, irrespective of whether Russia gets boos or how sickly sweet the lyrics are.

    Austria will do what their country wants them to do – not be rubbish, get a reasonable amount of points and not be embarrassed. Job done there – mid table safety.

    France will pick up good jury votes but I think that today’s Eurovision audience don’t want to listen to anything that isn’t sung in English, unfortunately. I like her singing but this will end up 15-20th.

    Serbia, Serbia, Serbia! I liked this in its native tongue but not now. I don’t think this will qualify as it needed to be a ballad OR an up-tempo club anthem, not both.

    Ireland chose the wrong song for 2015 but the right one for 1996! Molly is cute, she’s sings well and she’ll have a great career as a singer-songwriter but the EBU have killed any chance she has of qualifying by putting her 2nd in SF2, after the boy-girl fun duet of Lithuania.

    If I was scoring these five with my 1-12 points, only Russia would be getting anything, probably 7 or 8.

    Looking at your next 5, I can guarantee who’ll be top with your jury because I’m out of step with most fans on that too!

    Still, if you want some help, let me know 😉

    Like

    • I welcome views that are at odds with everyone else’s! As a result I will put your name down as a first point of contact for next year’s reviews if you’re keen. I would have asked you this year, but I have had my members locked in for quite some time to make sure everything would come together according to my schedule (yes, I have a schedule). After doing the reviews collaboratively once, I don’t think I can go back to doing them solo, so I’ll be on the lookout for jurors in the future for sure.

      Well, Russia didn’t float our collective boat, but I don’t disagree (or, as Genealogy might have put it up until recently, don’t deny) that Polina is most likely headed for a strong top 10 finish. I’m actually glad to hear that she can nail a live vocal, because ‘A Million Voices’ is the kind of song that wouldn’t disguise a bad vocal job very well, and I’d rather sit through a great rendition of it than have my ears bleeding afterwards!

      It does seem like Austria are destined for a classic host country result – more Sweden 2013 than Denmark 2014. That doesn’t stop me from secretly hoping that they’ll stun us all and do better than expected. If nothing else, they better set the piano on fire at Eurovision.

      I don’t think France’s result (whatever it may be) would benefit or suffer if the song was in English. I don’t think it would make much difference at all. I can’t see the song itself getting off the ground – though no doubt Lisa will outdo Twin Twin, who just couldn’t fill up that big stage. I will be forever sad about that unless I find a way to undo that sad 😉 I can see it more in the range of 19th-24th on final night.

      I reckon Serbia’s ballad/disco-dance track works better than San Marino’s did in Malmö, but that’s about the most positive thing I can say about it. I don’t mind the genre change because it seems like no big deal in comparison to how much I detest the lyrics. Honestly, I hope you’re right and it doesn’t qualify. We know that Serbia isn’t invincible!

      I think Molly fits into 2015 quite nicely, but it will be a hard task for her to advance. Darn ORF.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Ali Nella Houd

    Hola J!

    Glad to see you’ve finally started delegating things. (The alternative would have been to work out how to clone yourself. Slightly scary thought, but fodder for the future series of epic sci-fi movies, in which ESC fanatics attempt to take over the universe … based on a true story, of course.).

    The EBJury has ranked these entrants in the same order as I did, except I had Ireland (my no. 17) below Serbia (my no. 10).

    So Jaz, does it go any way towards ameliorating your feelings of near nausea in relation to Serbia’s BND to know that there are also now versions in French, Spanish and German? Given BS will at this rate soon have a version in Pidgin, perhaps we could mitigate the risk of Jazgurgitation by writing an Australian version, that replaces the current “lame (English) lyrics” with something more wholesome, packed with Aussie goodness?

    Something like:

    “Strewth, I’m dinky-di.
    Ridgy-didge? Too right!
    Bonzer, beaut, figjam!
    Strewth, I’m dinky-di,
    Won’t shoot through like
    A Bondi tram!”

    Ok, it was just a first cut. Maybe I should work on the Pidgin version instead …

    ;0P

    Ali

    Like

    • This collaborative review thing was all just a ploy to allow me to put ‘willing to strike a balance between delegating and sharing the workload’ on my CV. You’re onto me!!

      All I want from Serbia is the Serbian version 😥 Though I applaud your efforts in creating a true blue edition. Perhaps Guy could perform a duet with Bojana using those lyrics??

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Just in short my points for this selection of countries and songs:

    1. Austria – 7 points: I think they deserve another Top 10 placement for this, but the staging needs to be improved. The piano on fire is not enough, it needs something more stunning!

    2. Serbia – 6 points: I would have preferred the original version, too, but “Beauty never lies” (Does she mean Mans?!) now reminds me a bit on ‘Je ne sais quoi’ by Hera Björk, at least its last minute! And it still grows on me!

    3. Russia – 4 points: I think Polina should sing her song in Russian, so that we all don’t understand a word of THOSE lyrics. Would be better! Why do Russian artists all want to ‘shine’ that much in the last few years?! At least the song is much better than last year’s.
    BTW, “A million voices” would be the right title for Armenia this year, maybe we can change that once again, not? 😉

    4. France – 3 points: It’s a nice try to get something similar on stage as Natasha St. Pier and Sandrine Francois, who were very successful at Eurovision. But this time France will fail with their ballad, IMO!

    5. Ireland – 2 points: just two words: TINA AWARD! The dog is still inside at his warm fire place, already fallen asleep! Yaaaawwwnnn!

    Unfortunately, none of these songs would have got any of my 1 – 12 points, as they are all far away from my Top 10! 😉

    Like

    • Woohoo, Austria on top! I, at least, am happy to see that. Maybe The Makemakes should just set everything on fire? Their instruments, their clothes, the stage…it would be hot 😉 As long as the Stadthalle smoke alarms are temporarily disabled and there’s fire services present, it should be fine.

      I agree, Russia’s song IS better this year…which scares me. If the twins managed to do so well, how high is Polina going to go?

      Like

  1. Pingback: VIENNESE VERDICTS | The EBJ Jury Reviews (Part 2) | Eurovision by Jaz

  2. Pingback: VIENNESE VERDICTS | The EBJ Jury Reviews (Part 4) | Eurovision by Jaz

  3. Pingback: VIENNESE VERDICTS | The EBJ Jury Reviews (Part 8) + Our 2015 Top 40! | Eurovision by Jaz

Thinking it? Say it!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: