The 2009 split results are in!!!

1 Norway (1) Norway Norway
2 Iceland (2) Azerbaijan Iceland
3 United Kingdom (5) Turkey Azerbaijan
4 France (8) Iceland Turkey
5 Estonia (6) Greece United Kingdom
6 Denmark  (13)      Estonia Estonia
7 Turkey (4) Bosnia & Herzegovina Greece
8 Azerbaijan (3) Russia France
9 Israel (16) Armenia Bosnia & Herzegovina
10 Moldova (14) United Kingdom Armenia
11 Greece (7) Albania Russia
12 Bosnia & Herzegovina (9) Ukraine Ukraine
13 Malta (22) Moldova Denmark
14 Germany (20) Romania Moldova
15 Armenia (10) Sweden Portugal
16 Ukraine (12) Croatia Israel
17 Russia (11) France Albania
18 Portugal (15) Portugal Croatia
19 Croatia (18) Denmark Romania
20 Lithuania (23) Lithuania Germany
21 Romania (19) Spain Sweden
22 Sweden (21) Finland Malta
23 Albania (17) Germany Lithuania
24 Finland (25) Malta Spain
25 Spain (24) Israel Finland

Above you can see a table that I have compiled showing how Eurovision 2009 would have resulted if either the jury or the televoters had possessed all the deciding power. There are not too many drastic differences from the eventual combined rankings, although I am sure nations such as Azerbaijan are glad that the jury’s 8th place for them turned to a bronze medal thanks to the people at home. Similarly, I can only imagine how bitter countries like Malta are in that the professionals thought much more highly of their entries than the slightly partisan viewers. And that is what all of this chaos comes down to – the whole reason for reintroducing the juries was to reduce the effect of bloc voting on Eurovision.

So did it work?

Looking at how only the televoters doled out their points compared to the combined results, it looks like the answer is not a definitive yes, but a quite possibly. When was the last time the UK and France were out of the hellish bottom of the scoreboard? Quite a while. And we can see that countries who have taken their places, such as Sweden (who have a few neighbours that they can usually rely on to help them reach the top) have been negatively affected. But for some, like Germany and Spain, the battle is far from over.

In my opinion, the jury should be kept, and perhaps have their power increased over the next few years to ensure that it is the song, and not the nationality, that is the focus. But let’s hope they don’t eliminate the fun of televoting for good one day (not that I can; I have to get my European online friends to do it for me). Aurovoir.

Start the Eurovision conversation

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Basic HTML is allowed. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: